Who's Watching the Watchmen?
Mar. 6th, 2009 11:14 amWell, Me. Last night at midnight.
I read the novel for the first time about a year ago. And yes, as many say, it is probably the best Graphic Novel ever written, and one of the great pieces of 20th century literature, period. I finished reading it again a few days ago, and every time I read it I just fall more in love with it... it's subtlety, layers, complexity, and irony. It's just a great work. Really.
So, last night I was really excited to go to the midnight showing with a friend last night. My overall opinion is that it wasn't perfect. That there are things that I did have a problem with, and not the "ZOMG On page three of issue nine he clearly goes into the second door on the right but in the movie it's the third door. What were they THINKING!" but I mean actual real issues.
But, I thought it was overall amazingly well cast. Most of the leads were flawless. It was visually everything we could have hoped for, and while we of course lost some of its beloved complexity and subtlety, I think the movie was an overall a win. A-.
( Detailed Review: Cut for Spoilers, both for the movie AND if you haven't read it, the book )
Anyway, I'm sure that was all TL;DR but... oh well.
Enjoy your weekend everybody.
I read the novel for the first time about a year ago. And yes, as many say, it is probably the best Graphic Novel ever written, and one of the great pieces of 20th century literature, period. I finished reading it again a few days ago, and every time I read it I just fall more in love with it... it's subtlety, layers, complexity, and irony. It's just a great work. Really.
So, last night I was really excited to go to the midnight showing with a friend last night. My overall opinion is that it wasn't perfect. That there are things that I did have a problem with, and not the "ZOMG On page three of issue nine he clearly goes into the second door on the right but in the movie it's the third door. What were they THINKING!" but I mean actual real issues.
But, I thought it was overall amazingly well cast. Most of the leads were flawless. It was visually everything we could have hoped for, and while we of course lost some of its beloved complexity and subtlety, I think the movie was an overall a win. A-.
( Detailed Review: Cut for Spoilers, both for the movie AND if you haven't read it, the book )
Anyway, I'm sure that was all TL;DR but... oh well.
Enjoy your weekend everybody.